| the Apache XML site |

| Home |

| Development |

# FOP FAQ

print-friendly
PDF

### Questions

- 1. General questions
  - What is FOP?
  - What can I do with FOP?
  - What does "FOP" stand for?
  - How does FOP interact with other Apache Projects?
  - What is XSL?
  - What is XSL-FO?
  - What is XSLT?
  - How can I contribute?
- 2. Problems running FOP
  - I get the error: [ERROR]: 'master-reference' for 'fo:page-sequence'matches no 'simple-page-master' or 'page-sequence-master'
  - I get a NoClassDefFound exception.
  - I get a NoSuchMethodException or a NoSuchFieldException exception.
  - I get an OutOfMemoryException.
  - I get a MalformedURLException.
  - I get an "[ERROR]: null", or a NullPointerException.
  - FOP returns the message "[ERROR] object|property - 'x' is not implemented yet." When will it be implemented?
  - FOP hangs. FOP does not exit.
  - FOP runs forever, writing lots of ">" to the log.
  - FOP cannot find a file for fo:external-graphics.
  - FOP does not find my fonts.
- 3. Problems with FOP output
  - Leaders don't work anymore in 0.20.5. Instead of filling the line, only three dots or a short ruler is output.
  - Why does FOP insert a blank page between my page sequences?
  - Why is my graphic not rendered?
  - My graphical images do not work properly.
  - Why is my graphic rendered at a different resolution than it was created?
  - Keep-with-next, keep-with-previous, keep-together don't work.
  - My tables are missing, or missing their content.
  - Text overflowing table cells and the like is not clipped. Long text flows into adjacent cells/block, obscuring stuff there.
  - Page numbers are not properly right aligned.
  - Hyphenation does not work.
- 4. Embedding FOP. Using FOP in a servlet.
  - How do I use FOP in a servlet?
  - How do I use FOP in a servlet with an XSLT transformation?
  - How do I pass parameters to the XSLT transformation?
  - How do I use my own fonts when running FOP from a servlet?
  - How do I set the baseDir property in a servlet environment?
  - How do I use a user configuration file from a servlet?
  - I keep getting NoClassDefFound and other exceptions. How do I get FOP working for various servlet engines?
  - Can FOP be used in multithreaded environments?
- 5. SVG specific questions
  - The rendering of SVG text in my PDF is of poor quality. Can I control this?
  - How do I use FOP with SVG on headless servers?
  - FOP does not exit if a SVG is included.
  - I have problems with SVG referring to gradients etc. using "uri(#stuff)". I get a MalformedURLException.
  - Why is my SVG rendered at a size different from that specified in my fo:external-graphic element?
- 6. PDF specific (includes Acrobat peculiarities)
  - How do I embed fonts in PDF?
  - Some characters are not displayed, or displayed incorrectly, or displayed as “#”.
  - What tools are available for post-processing my PDF document?
  - How do I add security features (encryption, disable printing) to my PDF document?
  - How do I add document properties (title, author, etc.) to my PDF document?
  - How do I add watermarks to my PDF document?
  - The PDF is printed contorted!
  - How do I control the Acrobat bookmark display?
- 7. IEx specific stuff
  - The FOP servlet is called multiple times!
  - How do I print PDF directly from the browser?
- 8. General questions regarding XSLT, XSLFO, and basic XML
  - (FO) How do I vertically center an image or a table (or whatever)?
  - (FO) How do I center a table horizontally?
  - (FO) How to get page numbers printed on the "outer side" of the page (for books, for example)?
  - (FO) How do I use different static content for odd and even pages?
  - (FO) How do I get a special header on the first page?
  - (FO) How do I omit my headers on a blank page? How do I write "This page is left blank" on an intentionally blank page?
  - (FO) How do I print an Euro sign, a checkbox or other some other special symbols?
  - (FO) How do I keep linebreaks and hard spaces? How do I get preformatted text displayed as expected?
  - (FO) How do I print the total number of pages, for example "page 1 of 12"
  - (FO) The header overlaps body content. The body extends into the footer.
  - (FO) How do I get lines in the document, as separators, side bars or folding marks?
  - (FO) How do I validate my FO document?
  - (XML) How do I get a non-breaking space in FO? There are complaints about &nbsp;.
  - (XML) How do I enter special characters in XML? There are complaints about undefined entities, such as &uuml;, which work in HTML.
  - (XML) There are complaints about illegal characters and entities in the input.
  - (XML) There are complaints about illegal bytes or characters in the input. There are odd characters in the result.
- 9. General suggestions. How to solve problems.
  - I think I have found a bug in FOP. What should I do?
  - I have questions that are not addressed in this FAQ. Where should I post them?

### Answers

#### 1. General questions

##### 1.1. What is FOP?^

FOP is a print formatter for XSL formatting objects.

It can be used to render an XML file containing XSL formatting objects into a page layout. The main target is PDF but other rendering targets are supported, such as AWT, PCL, text and direct printing.

##### 1.2. What can I do with FOP?^

FOP provides both an application and a library that converts an XSL FO document into paginated output.

The FOP command line application can be directly used to transform XML into PDF, PostScript, PCL and other formats, there is also an AWT based viewer integrated.

The library can be used in servlets and other Java applications.

##### 1.3. What does "FOP" stand for?^

It's an acronym for Formatting Object Processor

##### 1.4. How does FOP interact with other Apache Projects?^

FOP is distributed with Cocoon as a PDF serializer for XSL (FO) documents.

Batik can be used with FOP to transcode an SVG image into a PDF document.

##### 1.5. What is XSL?^

XSL is a W3C standard concerned with publishing XML documents. It consists of two parts: XSLT and XSLFO. The acronym expands to eXtensible Stylesheet Language.

##### 1.6. What is XSL-FO?^

XSLFO is an XML vocabulary that is used to specify a pagination and other styling for page layout output. The acronym “FO” stands for Formatting Objects. XSLFO can be used in conjunction with XSLT to convert from any XML format into a paginated layout ready for printing or displaying.

XSLFO defines a set of elements in XML that describes the way pages are set up. The contents of the pages are filled from flows. There can be static flows that appear on every page (for headers and footers) and the main flow which fills the body of the page.

Synonyms: XSL FO, XSL (FO), XSL:FO, XSL-FO, Formatting Objects

##### 1.7. What is XSLT?^

XSLT describes the transformation of arbitrary XML input into other XML (like XSLFO), HTML or plain text. The “T” comes from Transformation. For historical reasons, a transformation is often also called a “style sheet”.

Synonyms: XSL transformation, XSL:T, XSL style sheet.

##### 1.8. How can I contribute?^

There are numerous ways that you can help. They are outlined in the Developer's Introduction.

#### 2. Problems running FOP

##### 2.1. I get the error: [ERROR]: 'master-reference' for 'fo:page-sequence'matches no 'simple-page-master' or 'page-sequence-master'^

FOP was changed to be in accordance with the latest standard (see XSL standard).The page master for a fo:page-sequence is now refereced by the master-reference attribute. Replace the master-name attributes of your fo:page-sequence elements by master-reference attributes. You have to do this also for fo:single-page-master-reference, fo:repeatable-page-master-reference and fo:conditional-page-master-reference elements in you page master definitions.

Update your FO documents and style sheets.

##### 2.2. I get a NoClassDefFound exception.^

This is typically a problem with your classpath.

If you are running FOP from the command line:

- Use the fop.bat or fop.sh command file from the FOP distribution. If you have a FOP version older than 0.20.5, ensure the directory where FOP and these files have been installed is the current working directory.
- If this doesn't help, check whether still all the jar files mentioned in the classpath in the fop.bat file are in their respective places.

If you run FOP embedded in your servlet, web application or other Java application, check the classpath of the application. Check the also the information pertaining servlet engines for further hints.

##### 2.3. I get a NoSuchMethodException or a NoSuchFieldException exception.^

This is usually caused by an older version of one of the FOP jars or old XML tools in the classpath. Check in particular for parser.jar, jaxp.jar, xml4j.jar or lotusxsl.jar.

Incompatible versions of Batik may also cause this problem. Use the version of Batik that comes with FOP. It is not always possible to use a more recent version of Batik.

##### 2.4. I get an OutOfMemoryException.^

See FOP Memory.

##### 2.5. I get a MalformedURLException.^

What you probably think of as "file names" are usually URLs, in particular the src attribute of fo:external-graphic.

Because usage of URLs is growing, you should make yourself familiar with it. The relevant specification is RFC 2396.

In a nutshell, the correct syntax for an absolute file URL is file:///some/path/file.ext on Unix and file:///z:/some/path/file.ext on Windows systems. Note the triple slash, and also that only forward slashes are used, even on windows.

A relative file URL starts with anything but a slash, and doesn't have the file: prefix, for example file.ext, path/file.ext or ../file.ext. The string file:path/file.ext is not a relative URL, in fact, it isn't a valid URL at all. A relative URL is subject to a resolving process, which transforms it into an absolute URL.

##### 2.6. I get an "[ERROR]: null", or a NullPointerException.^

This is often caused by an invalid FO document. Currently only very common errors are intercepted and produce a comprehensible error message. If you forgot container elements like fo:page-sequence or fo:flow and put blocks and inline elements directly as children of fo:root or fo:page-sequence, you'll only get a NullPointerException. Check whether your FO file has a proper structure. In some cases there are mandatory properties, like the master-reference in fo:conditional-page-master-reference, check also whether you got them right.

You may find it helpful to use the validation tools to validate your FO document. This will catch most problems, but should not be relied upon to catch all.

If you use XSLT, problems in your style sheet and in your source XML also can produce a NullPointerException. Run the transformation separately to check for this, usually you'll get a detailed error message from the XSLT processor.

If you turn on debugging with the "-d" option you may be able to see more detailed information.

##### 2.7. FOP returns the message "[ERROR] object|property - 'x' is not implemented yet." When will it be implemented?^

See the article "Review FOP's Standards Compliance".

##### 2.8. FOP hangs. FOP does not exit.^

The most likely reason is a known problem with the Java run time environment which is triggered by rendering SVGs. Suns JDK 1.4 does not have this problem. See also FOP does not exit if a SVG is included.

Another possibility is that FOP went into a non terminating loop. Usually this is indicated by lots of log messages of the form "[INFO]: [NNNN]" which indicate a new page has been started or box overflows. After some time, FOP will crash with an OutOfMemoryException.

If you called the FOP command line application from some other programm, for example from Java using Runtime.exec(), it may hang while trying to write log entries to the output pipe. You have to read the FOP output regularly to empty the pipe buffer. It is best to avoid exec'ing FOP, use the library interface instead.

##### 2.9. FOP runs forever, writing lots of ">" to the log.^

There is something too large to fit into the intended place, usually a large image, a table whose rows are kept together or a block with a space-before or space-after larger than the page size. Catch the first page showing this phenomenon and check it. If it is not obvious which element causes the trouble, remove stuff until the problem goes away. Decrease the dimensions of the offending element or property, or increase the dimension of the enclosing element or container, or remove keep-with-* properties.

##### 2.10. FOP cannot find a file for fo:external-graphics.^

The src attribute of the fo:external-graphics element requires a URI, not a file name. See External Resources for more information about specifying URIs.

##### 2.11. FOP does not find my fonts.^

Did you get: «Failed to read font metrics file C:\foo\arial.xml : File "C:\foo\arial.xml" not found»? The value for the metrics-file attribute in the user config file is actually an URL, not a file name. Use "file:///C:/foo/arial.xml" instead.

If you used a relative URL, make sure your application has the working directory you expect. Currently FOP does not use the baseDir for resolving relative URLs pointing to font metric files.

Try also setting the fontBaseDir configuration. (FIXME: add link to congfiguration page)

#### 3. Problems with FOP output

##### 3.1. Leaders don't work anymore in 0.20.5. Instead of filling the line, only three dots or a short ruler is output.^

Leaders still work, in fact they work better than ever before. You'll just have to add text-align="justify" and/or text-align-last="justify" to the block with the leader. Be sure you haven't accidentally overridden the leader-length.maximum="100%" default value.

Earlier versions of FOP used to expand a leader to fill the rest of the line unconditionally, anything following it, like page numbers in a TOC, was actually shifted beyong the right margin.

The new implementation uses leader-length.optimum to determine where to break the line, and expands the leader only further if the line should be filled, as indicated by the text-aling and text-align-last properties.

Actually due to the fuzzyness of the specification both the old and the new method are conformant (although adding text after the expanded leader in the old variant never was).

If you want to have a longer ruler or space in a non-justified line, you have to increase the leader-length.optimum property.

##### 3.2. Why does FOP insert a blank page between my page sequences?^

This is because spec conformance has been improved.

The force-page-count property controls how a FO processor pads page sequences in order to get certain page counts or last page numbers. The default is "auto". With this setting, if the next page sequence begins with an odd page number because you set the initial-page-number, and the current page sequence also ends with an odd page number, the processor inserts a blank page to keep odd and even page numbers alternating (similar for the case the current page sequence ends with an even page number and the next page sequence starts with an even page number.

If you don't want to have this blank page, use force-page-count="no-force".

##### 3.3. Why is my graphic not rendered?^

Most commonly, the external file is not being found by FOP. Check the following:

- Empty or wrong baseDir setting.
- Spelling errors in the file name (including using the wrong case).
- Security Problems (i.e. image was not delivered because FOP is not allowed to read the file). This is especially a problem if the external file is retrieved over HTTP. Possible issues include security settings on the server, server configuration, and missing cookies or other authorization information. Any easy way to check this is to cut&paste the source URL from the fo:external-graphic into the Location field of a browser on the machine where the FOP process will be running.

Other possibilities:

- The image format is not supported or not supported completely. See FOP Graphics Formats for a list of supported formats and related issues.
- The graphic may be too large to fit into the intended space.
- There may be something (static content) that is obscuring the graphic. (This is very rare).

##### 3.4. My graphical images do not work properly.^

See FOP Graphics Formats for a list of supported formats and related issues.

##### 3.5. Why is my graphic rendered at a different resolution than it was created?^

See Graphics Resolution.

##### 3.6. Keep-with-next, keep-with-previous, keep-together don't work.^

These properties are not implemented, except on table rows. In order to take advantage of them, you have to nest stuff to be kept together in a table.

The concept is called “blind table”. The table is used for pure layout reasons and not obvious in the output.

An example of an image and the image caption to be kept together:

    <fo:table table-layout="fixed" width="100%">
      <fo:table-column column-width="proportional-column-width(1)"/>
      <fo:table-body>
        <fo:table-row keep-with-next="always">
          <fo:table-cell>
            <fo:block>
              <fo:external-graphic src="foo.jpg"/>
            </fo:block>
          </fo:table-cell>
        </fo:table-row>
        <fo:table-row>
          <fo:table-cell>
            <fo:block>Image Caption</fo:block>
          </fo:table-cell>
        </fo:table-row>
      </fo:table-body>
    </fo:table>

##### 3.7. My tables are missing, or missing their content.^

Check for fo:table-body around the rows. FOP up to 0.20.4 doesn't raise an error if it is omitted, it just drops the content. More recent releases will catch this problem.

Also, the fo:table-with-caption element is not implemented, tables within such an element are dropped too. FOP generates an error message for this problem. The DocBook style sheets generate fo:table-with-caption elements, so watch out.

##### 3.8. Text overflowing table cells and the like is not clipped. Long text flows into adjacent cells/block, obscuring stuff there.^

Clipping as specified by the overflow="hidden" is not yet implemented. If you have long words overflowing table cells, try to get them hyphenated. Artificial names like product identifications or long numbers usually aren't hyphenated. You can try special processing at XSLT level, like

- clip long text,
- explicit wrapping+clipping,
- insert zero width spaces (U+200B or &#x200B;) to allow FOP to wrap.

Check the XSL FAQ and the XSL list archive for how to perform these tasks.

##### 3.9. Page numbers are not properly right aligned.^

This happens for fo:page-number-citation elements if the citation occurs before FOP formatted the requested page, usually in TOC or index pages. It is caused by the problem that FOP has to guess how much space the yet unknown page number will occupy, and usually the guesses are somewhat off.

The most recent FOP releases should have this problem fixed. Check whether you can upgrade.

##### 3.10. Hyphenation does not work.^

Set the language attribute somewhere and explicitly enable hyphenation. Check whether you use a language for which hyphenation is supported. Supported languages can be deduced from the files in the {fop-dir}/src/hyph directory of the FOP source distribution. If you want to use a language FOP currently doesn't hyphenate, please see the Configuration page.

Set the language (on fo:page-sequence, fo:block or fo:character):

    <fo:page-sequence language="fi">

Enable hyphenation on a block:

    <fo:block hyphenate="true">

#### 4. Embedding FOP. Using FOP in a servlet.

##### 4.1. How do I use FOP in a servlet?^

See Using FOP in a Servlet.

##### 4.2. How do I use FOP in a servlet with an XSLT transformation?^

See Using FOP in a Servlet with XSLT Transformation.

##### 4.3. How do I pass parameters to the XSLT transformation?^

See Using FOP in a Servlet with XSLT Transformation.

##### 4.4. How do I use my own fonts when running FOP from a servlet?^

Declare the fonts in the userconfig.xml file as usual. See loading the user configuration file for further details.

##### 4.5. How do I set the baseDir property in a servlet environment?^

See Setting the Configuration Programmatically.

##### 4.6. How do I use a user configuration file from a servlet?^

See Using a Configuration File in an Embedded App.

##### 4.7. I keep getting NoClassDefFound and other exceptions. How do I get FOP working for various servlet engines?^

See Servlet Engines.

##### 4.8. Can FOP be used in multithreaded environments?^

See Multithreading FOP.

#### 5. SVG specific questions

##### 5.1. The rendering of SVG text in my PDF is of poor quality. Can I control this?^

See Placing SVG Text into PDF.

##### 5.2. How do I use FOP with SVG on headless servers?^

See FOP: Graphics (Batik).

##### 5.3. FOP does not exit if a SVG is included.^

Applies to older FOP versions and JDK 1.3 and older. That's because there is an AWT thread hanging around. The solution is to put a System.exit(0) somewhere.

##### 5.4. I have problems with SVG referring to gradients etc. using "uri(#stuff)". I get a MalformedURLException.^

This is really a "resolving relative URI" problem with some twists. The problem is that the #stuff URL fragment identifier is resolved within the current SVG document. So the reference must be valid within the XML subset and it cannot reference other SVG documents in the same XML file. Some options to try:

- Put the SVG into a separate file and use it with fo:external-graphics.
- Use a separate SVG file which contains only the gradient (and perhaps other SVG stuff you want to reference) and point an absolute URL to it: fill="url(file:///c:/refstuff/grad.svg#PurpleToWhite)".
- Same as above but use a relative URL: fill="url(grad.svg#PurpleToWhite)". This may be easier to deploy.
- Make sure that the reference is valid in the current SVG document.

In any case, the referenced stuff has to be pointed to by an URL. It doesn't necessarily have to be a file URL, HTTP should also work. Also, expect a performance hit in all cases, because another XML file has to be retrieved and parsed.

Ultimately, both FOP and especially Batik should be fixed to make your code work as expected, but this will not only take some time but also some effort by a standard committee in order to make the semantics of this kind of references in embedded SVG clearer.

See also MalformedURLException

##### 5.5. Why is my SVG rendered at a size different from that specified in my fo:external-graphic element?^

See SVG Scaling.

#### 6. PDF specific (includes Acrobat peculiarities)

##### 6.1. How do I embed fonts in PDF?^

See the Fonts page for information about embedding fonts.

##### 6.2. Some characters are not displayed, or displayed incorrectly, or displayed as “#”.^

This usually means the selected font doesn't have a glyph for the character.

The standard text fonts supplied with Acrobat Reader have mostly glyphs for characters from the ISO Latin 1 character set. For a variety of reasons, even those are not completely guaranteed to work, for example you can't use the fi ligature from the standard serif font. Check the overview for the default PDF fonts.

If you use your own fonts, the font must have a glyph for the desired character. Furthermore the font must be available on the machine where the PDF is viewed or it must have been embedded in the PDF file. See embedding fonts.

For most symbols, it is better to select the symbol font explicitely, for example in order to get the symbol for the mathematical empty set, write:

    <fo:inline font-family="Symbol">&#x2205;</fo:inline>

The "#" shows up if the selected font does not define a glyph for the required character, for example if you try:

    <fo:inline font-family="Helvetica">&#x2205;</fo:inline>

##### 6.3. What tools are available for post-processing my PDF document?^

See PDF Post-processing.

##### 6.4. How do I add security features (encryption, disable printing) to my PDF document?^

See PDF Encryption. See also PDF Post-processing.

##### 6.5. How do I add document properties (title, author, etc.) to my PDF document?^

See PDF Post-processing.

##### 6.6. How do I add watermarks to my PDF document?^

See PDF Watermarks.

##### 6.7. The PDF is printed contorted!^

Check the paper size in Acrobat settings and the "fit to page" print setting. Contorted printing is often caused by a mismatched paper format, for example if the setting is "US Letter" but the PDF was made for A4. Sometimes also the printer driver interferes, check its settings too.

##### 6.8. How do I control the Acrobat bookmark display?^

FOP does not currently support this feature. Possible workarounds include those mentioned in the PDF Post-Processing FAQ.

#### 7. IEx specific stuff

##### 7.1. The FOP servlet is called multiple times!^

This is a problem of Internet Explorer requesting the content several times. Please see the notes on Internet Explorer for more information.

##### 7.2. How do I print PDF directly from the browser?^

It depends whether you mean "printing to a printer under control of the server" or "printing on the client's printer".

For the first problem, look at the print servlet in the FOP examples. You'll have to gather any printer settings in a HTML form and send it to the server.

For the second task, you can use some client side script to start Acrobat Reader in print mode, or use a Java applet based on the FOP print servlet. This depends heavily on the client installation and should not relied on except in tightly controlled environments.

See also http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=fop-dev&m=101065988325115&w=2

#### 8. General questions regarding XSLT, XSLFO, and basic XML

##### 8.1. (FO) How do I vertically center an image or a table (or whatever)?^

See XSL-FO Vertical Centering.

##### 8.2. (FO) How do I center a table horizontally?^

See XSL-FO Horizontal Centering (Tables).

##### 8.3. (FO) How to get page numbers printed on the "outer side" of the page (for books, for example)?^

See Recto/Verso Static Content Differences.

##### 8.4. (FO) How do I use different static content for odd and even pages?^

See Recto/Verso Static Content Differences.

##### 8.5. (FO) How do I get a special header on the first page?^

See Making the First Page Special.

##### 8.6. (FO) How do I omit my headers on a blank page? How do I write "This page is left blank" on an intentionally blank page?^

See Blank Pages.

##### 8.7. (FO) How do I print an Euro sign, a checkbox or other some other special symbols?^

See Special Characters.

##### 8.8. (FO) How do I keep linebreaks and hard spaces? How do I get preformatted text displayed as expected?^

See Preformatting Content.

##### 8.9. (FO) How do I print the total number of pages, for example "page 1 of 12"^

See Total Document Pages.

##### 8.10. (FO) The header overlaps body content. The body extends into the footer.^

See Aligning Regions.

##### 8.11. (FO) How do I get lines in the document, as separators, side bars or folding marks?^

See Drawing Lines.

##### 8.12. (FO) How do I validate my FO document?^

See Validating XSL-FO.

##### 8.13. (XML) How do I get a non-breaking space in FO? There are complaints about &nbsp;.^

See XML Special Characters.

##### 8.14. (XML) How do I enter special characters in XML? There are complaints about undefined entities, such as &uuml;, which work in HTML. ^

See XML Special Characters.

##### 8.15. (XML) There are complaints about illegal characters and entities in the input.^

See Using HTML Character Names.

##### 8.16. (XML) There are complaints about illegal bytes or characters in the input. There are odd characters in the result.^

See XML Encoding Issues.

#### 9. General suggestions. How to solve problems.

##### 9.1. I think I have found a bug in FOP. What should I do?^

See the Bugs page for information about bugs already reported and how to report new ones.

##### 9.2. I have questions that are not addressed in this FAQ. Where should I post them?^

- If your question is a development-related question, please see the Developer FAQs.
- If you have a runtime exception or other runtime problem:
  - double-check the Runtime FAQs.
  - ClassNotFoundException, NoSuchMethodException and NoSuchFieldException problems are almost always a problem with the local environment. Try to get local help first.
  - Check Reported Issues to see if this is a known problem.
  - If none of the above apply, post a question to the fop-dev mailing list.
- In the case where something works properly with another formatter, (AntennaHouse, PassiveTex, etc.) but doesn't work with FOP, please check the Release Notes, the FOP Standards Compliance document, and the remaining FAQ in this document. If not found there, look at the list of Bugs Already Reported. If not found there, please post a question on the fop-user mailing list or Open a New Bug.
- Question about how to use FOP, how to perform certain tasks with FOP or how to integrate FOP into another application should be posted to fop-user.
- XSLT specific stuff sould go to the XSL list. This includes problems with the language and XSLT HOW-TOs.
- Problems specific to a certain XSLT processor, like Xalan, Saxon or MSXML, should be handled by processor specific lists. This includes problems with deployment, processor specific extensions, suspected bugs and processor specific APIs. Note that JDK 1.4 comes with an XML parser and an XSLT processor which are older versions of Xerces and Xalan, respectively, and both have a number of annoying bugs. See $$$FIXME on how to use more recent versions or other packages instead.
- Problems with servlet containers should be asked on the vendor specific lists for these software packages.
- More general questions regarding Java, including deployment, Java APIs, classpath issues and property definitions should be redirected to some Java specific list.

Copyright © 1999-2003 The Apache Software Foundation. All rights reserved.