                      FreeBSD Release Engineering

  Murray Stokely

   <murray@FreeBSD.org>
               
             

   $FreeBSD: doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/articles/releng/article.sgml,v 1.85
   2009/11/28 19:55:51 hrs Exp $

   FreeBSD is a registered trademark of the FreeBSD Foundation.

   CVSup is a registered trademark of John D. Polstra.

   Intel, Celeron, EtherExpress, i386, i486, Itanium, Pentium, and
   Xeon are trademarks or registered trademarks of Intel Corporation
   or its subsidiaries in the United States and other countries.

   XFree86 is a trademark of The XFree86 Project, Inc.

   Many of the designations used by manufacturers and sellers to
   distinguish their products are claimed as trademarks. Where those
   designations appear in this document, and the FreeBSD Project was
   aware of the trademark claim, the designations have been followed
   by the "(TM)" or the "(R)" symbol.

   This paper describes the approach used by the FreeBSD release
   engineering team to make production quality releases of the
   FreeBSD Operating System. It details the methodology used for the
   official FreeBSD releases and describes the tools available for
   those interested in producing customized FreeBSD releases for
   corporate rollouts or commercial productization.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

1 Introduction

   The development of FreeBSD is a very open process. FreeBSD is
   comprised of contributions from thousands of people around the
   world. The FreeBSD Project provides anonymous CVS[1] access to the
   general public so that others can have access to log messages,
   diffs (patches) between development branches, and other
   productivity enhancements that formal source code management
   provides. This has been a huge help in attracting more talented
   developers to FreeBSD. However, I think everyone would agree that
   chaos would soon manifest if write access was opened up to
   everyone on the Internet. Therefore only a "select" group of
   nearly 300 people are given write access to the CVS repository.
   These committers[5] are responsible for the bulk of FreeBSD
   development. An elected core-team[6] of very senior developers
   provides some level of direction over the project.

   The rapid pace of FreeBSD development leaves little time for
   polishing the development system into a production quality
   release. To solve this dilemma, development continues on two
   parallel tracks. The main development branch is the HEAD or trunk
   of our CVS tree, known as "FreeBSD-CURRENT" or "-CURRENT" for
   short.

   A more stable branch is maintained, known as "FreeBSD-STABLE" or
   "-STABLE" for short. Both branches live in a master CVS repository
   in California and are replicated via CVSup[2] to mirrors all over
   the world. FreeBSD-CURRENT[7] is the "bleeding-edge" of FreeBSD
   development where all new changes first enter the system.
   FreeBSD-STABLE is the development branch from which major releases
   are made. Changes go into this branch at a different pace, and
   with the general assumption that they have first gone into
   FreeBSD-CURRENT and have been thoroughly tested by our user
   community.

   In the interim period between releases, monthly snapshots are
   built automatically by the FreeBSD Project build machines and made
   available for download from
   ftp://ftp.freebsd.org/pub/FreeBSD/snapshots/. The widespread
   availability of binary release snapshots, and the tendency of our
   user community to keep up with -STABLE development with CVSup and
   "make world"[7] helps to keep FreeBSD-STABLE in a very reliable
   condition even before the quality assurance activities ramp up
   pending a major release.

   Bug reports and feature requests are continuously submitted by
   users throughout the release cycle. Problems reports are entered
   into our GNATS[8] database through email, the send-pr(1)
   application, or via the web interface provided at
   http://www.FreeBSD.org/send-pr.html. In addition to the multitude
   of different technical mailing lists about FreeBSD, the FreeBSD
   Quality Assurance mailing list provides a forum for discussing the
   finer points of "release-polishing".

   To service our most conservative users, individual release
   branches were introduced with FreeBSD 4.3. These release branches
   are created shortly before a final release is made. After the
   release goes out, only the most critical security fixes and
   additions are merged onto the release branch. In addition to
   source updates via CVS, binary patchkits are available to keep
   systems on the RELENG_X_Y branches updated.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  1.1 What this article describes

   The following sections of this article describe:

   Section 2

           The different phases of the release engineering process
           leading up to the actual system build.

   Section 3

           The actual build process.

   Section 5

           How the base release may be extended by third parties.

   Section 6

           Some of the lessons learned through the release of
           FreeBSD 4.4.

   Section 7

           Future directions of development.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

2 Release Process

   New releases of FreeBSD are released from the -STABLE branch at
   approximately four month intervals. The FreeBSD release process
   begins to ramp up 45 days before the anticipated release date when
   the release engineer sends an email to the development mailing
   lists to remind developers that they only have 15 days to
   integrate new changes before the code freeze. During this time,
   many developers perform what have become known as "MFC sweeps".
   MFC stands for "Merge From CURRENT" and it describes the process
   of merging a tested change from our -CURRENT development branch to
   our -STABLE branch.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  2.1 Code Review

   Thirty days before the anticipated release, the source repository
   enters a "code slush". During this time, all commits to the
   -STABLE branch must be approved by the Release Engineering Team
   <re@FreeBSD.org>. The kinds of changes that are allowed during
   this 15 day period include:

     * Bug fixes.

     * Documentation updates.

     * Security-related fixes of any kind.

     * Minor changes to device drivers, such as adding new Device
       IDs.

     * Any additional change that the release engineering team feels
       is justified, given the potential risk.

   After the first 15 days of the code slush, a release candidate is
   released for widespread testing and the code enters a "code
   freeze" where it becomes much harder to justify new changes to the
   system unless a serious bug-fix or security issue is involved.
   During the code freeze, at least one release candidate is released
   per week, until the final release is ready. During the days
   leading to the final release, the release engineering team is in
   constant communication with the security-officer team, the
   documentation maintainers, and the port maintainers, to ensure
   that all of the different components required for a successful
   release are available.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  2.2 Final Release Checklist

   When several release candidates have been made available for
   widespread testing and all major issues have been resolved, the
   final release "polishing" can begin.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

    2.2.1 Creating the Release Branch

   As described in the introduction, the RELENG_X_Y release branch is
   a relatively new addition to our release engineering methodology.
   The first step in creating this branch is to ensure that you are
   working with the newest version of the RELENG_X sources that you
   want to branch from.

 /usr/src# cvs update -rRELENG_4 -P -d

   The next step is to create a branch point tag, so that diffs
   against the start of the branch are easier with CVS:

 /usr/src# cvs rtag -rRELENG_4 RELENG_4_8_BP src

   And then a new branch tag is created with:

 /usr/src# cvs rtag -b -rRELENG_4_8_BP RELENG_4_8 src

     Note: The RELENG_* tags are restricted for use by the
     CVS-meisters and release engineers.

   +----------------------------------------------------------------+
   | A "tag" is CVS vernacular for a label that identifies the      |
   | source at a specific point in time. By tagging the tree, we    |
   | ensure that future release builders will always be able to use |
   | the same source we used to create the official FreeBSD Project |
   | releases.                                                      |
   +----------------------------------------------------------------+

   FreeBSD Development Branch

   FreeBSD 3.x STABLE Branch

   FreeBSD 4.x STABLE Branch

   FreeBSD 5.x STABLE Branch

   FreeBSD 6.x STABLE Branch

   FreeBSD 7.x STABLE Branch

   FreeBSD 8.x STABLE Branch

     --------------------------------------------------------------

    2.2.2 Bumping up the Version Number

   Before the final release can be tagged, built, and released, the
   following files need to be modified to reflect the correct version
   of FreeBSD:

     * doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/books/handbook/mirrors/chapter.sgml

     * doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/books/porters-handbook/book.sgml

     * doc/share/sgml/freebsd.ent

     * src/Makefile.inc1

     * src/UPDATING

     * src/gnu/usr.bin/groff/tmac/mdoc.local

     * src/release/Makefile

     * src/release/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/share/sgml/release.dsl

     * src/release/doc/share/examples/Makefile.relnotesng

     * src/release/doc/share/sgml/release.ent

     * src/share/examples/cvsup/standard-supfile

     * src/sys/conf/newvers.sh

     * src/sys/sys/param.h

     * src/usr.sbin/pkg_install/add/main.c

     * www/en/docs/man.sgml

     * www/en/cgi/ports.cgi

     * ports/Tools/scripts/release/config

   The release notes and errata files also need to be adjusted for
   the new release (on the release branch) and truncated
   appropriately (on the stable/current branch):

     * src/release/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/relnotes/common/new.sgml

     * src/release/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/errata/article.sgml

   Sysinstall should be updated to note the number of available ports
   and the amount of disk space required for the Ports Collection[4].
   This information is currently kept in
   src/usr.sbin/sysinstall/dist.c.

   After the release has been built, a number of file should be
   updated to announce the release to the world.

     * doc/share/images/articles/releng/branches-relengX.pic

     * www/share/sgml/advisories.xml

     * www/share/sgml/includes.release.sgml

     * www/share/sgml/includes.release.xsl

     * www/en/releases/*

     * www/en/releng/index.sgml

     * www/en/news/news.xml

     * www/en/search/web.atoz

     * src/share/misc/bsd-family-tree

     --------------------------------------------------------------

    2.2.3 Preparing a new major release branch (RELENG_X)

   When a new major release branch, such as RELENG_6 is branched from
   HEAD, some additional files must be updated before releases can be
   made from this new branch.

     * src/share/examples/cvsup/stable-supfile - must be updated to
       point to the new -STABLE branch, when applicable.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

    2.2.4 Creating Release Tags

   When the final release is ready, the following command will create
   the RELENG_4_8_0_RELEASE tag.

 /usr/src# cvs rtag -rRELENG_4_8 RELENG_4_8_0_RELEASE src

   The Documentation and Ports managers are responsible for tagging
   the respective trees with the RELEASE_4_8_0 tag.

   Occasionally, a last minute fix may be required after the final
   tags have been created. In practice this is not a problem, since
   CVS allows tags to be manipulated with cvs tag -d tagname
   filename. It is very important that any last minute changes be
   tagged appropriately as part of the release. FreeBSD releases must
   always be reproducible. Local hacks in the release engineer's
   environment are not acceptable.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

3 Release Building

   FreeBSD "releases" can be built by anyone with a fast machine and
   access to a source repository. (That should be everyone, since we
   offer anonymous CVS! See The Handbook for details.) The only
   special requirement is that the vn(4) device must be available.
   (On -CURRENT, this device has been replaced by the new md(4)
   memory disk driver.) If the device is not loaded into your kernel,
   then the kernel module should be automatically loaded when
   vnconfig(8) is executed during the boot media creation phase. All
   of the tools necessary to build a release are available from the
   CVS repository in src/release. These tools aim to provide a
   consistent way to build FreeBSD releases. A complete release can
   actually be built with only a single command, including the
   creation of ISO images suitable for burning to CDROM, installation
   floppies, and an FTP install directory. This command is aptly
   named make release.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  3.1 make release

   To successfully build a release, you must first populate /usr/obj
   by running make world or simply make buildworld. The release
   target requires several variables be set properly to build a
   release:

     * CHROOTDIR - The directory to be used as the chroot environment
       for the entire release build.

     * BUILDNAME - The name of the release to be built.

     * CVSROOT - The location of a CVS Repository.

     * RELEASETAG - The CVS tag corresponding to the release you
       would like to build.

   If you do not already have access to a local CVS repository, then
   you may mirror one with CVSup. The supplied supfile,
   /usr/share/examples/cvsup/cvs-supfile, is a useful starting point
   for mirroring the CVS repository.

   If RELEASETAG is omitted, then the release will be built from the
   HEAD (a.k.a. -CURRENT) branch. Releases built from this branch are
   normally referred to as "-CURRENT snapshots".

   There are many other variables available to customize the release
   build. Most of these variables are documented at the top of
   src/release/Makefile. The exact command used to build the official
   FreeBSD 4.7 (x86) release was:

 make release CHROOTDIR=/local3/release \
        BUILDNAME=4.7-RELEASE \
        CVSROOT=/host/cvs/usr/home/ncvs \
        RELEASETAG=RELENG_4_7_0_RELEASE
       
     

   The release Makefile can be broken down into several distinct
   steps.

     * Creation of a sanitized system environment in a separate
       directory hierarchy with "make installworld".

     * Checkout from CVS of a clean version of the system source,
       documentation, and ports into the release build hierarchy.

     * Population of /etc and /dev in the chrooted environment.

     * chroot into the release build hierarchy, to make it harder for
       the outside environment to taint this build.

     * make world in the chrooted environment.

     * Build of Kerberos-related binaries.

     * Build GENERIC kernel.

     * Creation of a staging directory tree where the binary
       distributions will be built and packaged.

     * Build and installation of the documentation toolchain needed
       to convert the documentation source (SGML) into HTML and text
       documents that will accompany the release.

     * Build and installation of the actual documentation (user
       manuals, tutorials, release notes, hardware compatibility
       lists, and so on.)

     * Build of the "crunched" binaries used for installation
       floppies.

     * Package up distribution tarballs of the binaries and sources.

     * Create the boot media and a "fixit" floppy.

     * Create FTP installation hierarchy.

     * (optionally) Create ISO images for CDROM/DVD media.

   For more information about the release build infrastructure,
   please see release(7).

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  3.2 Building XFree86(TM)

   XFree86(TM) is an important component for many desktop users.
   Prior to FreeBSD 4.6-RELEASE, releases used XFree86 3.X by
   default. The easiest way to build these versions is to use the
   src/release/scripts/X11/build_x.sh script. This script requires
   that XFree86 and Tcl/Tk already be installed on the build host.
   After compiling the necessary X servers, the script will package
   all of the files into tarballs that sysinstall(8) expects to find
   in the XF86336 directory of the installation media.

   Beginning with FreeBSD 4.6-RELEASE, sysinstall(8) installs XFree86
   4.X by default, as a set of "normal" packages. These can either be
   the packages generated by the package-building cluster or packages
   built from an appropriately tagged ports tree.

   Beginning with FreeBSD 5.3-RELEASE, sysinstall(8) installs Xorg
   packages instead of XFree86 packages by default.

     Note: It is important to remove any site-specific settings from
     /etc/make.conf. For example, it would be unwise to distribute
     binaries that were built on a system with CPUTYPE set to a
     specific processor.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  3.3 Contributed Software ("ports")

   The FreeBSD Ports collection is a collection of over 20,000
   third-party software packages available for FreeBSD. The Ports
   Management Team <portmgr@FreeBSD.org> is responsible for
   maintaining a consistent ports tree that can be used to create the
   binary packages that accompany official FreeBSD releases.

   The release engineering activities for our collection of
   third-party packages is beyond the scope of this document. A
   separate article, The Release Engineering of Third Party Packages,
   covers this topic in depth.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  3.4 Release ISOs

   Starting with FreeBSD 4.4, the FreeBSD Project decided to release
   all four ISO images that were previously sold on the BSDi/Wind
   River Systems/FreeBSD Mall "official" CDROM distributions. Each of
   the four discs must contain a README.TXT file that explains the
   contents of the disc, a CDROM.INF file that provides meta-data for
   the disc so that sysinstall(8) can validate and use the contents,
   and a filename.txt file that provides a manifest for the disc.
   This manifest can be created with a simple command:

 /stage/cdrom# find . -type f | sed -e 's/^\.\///' | sort > filename.txt

   The specific requirements of each CD are outlined below.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

    3.4.1 Disc 1

   The first disc is almost completely created by make release. The
   only changes that should be made to the disc1 directory are the
   addition of a tools directory, XFree86, and as many popular third
   party software packages as will fit on the disc. The tools
   directory contains software that allow users to create
   installation floppies from other operating systems. This disc
   should be made bootable so that users of modern PCs do not need to
   create installation floppy disks.

   If a custom kernel of FreeBSD is to be included, then
   sysinstall(8) and release(7) must be updated to include
   installation instructions. The relevant code is contained in
   src/release and src/usr.sbin/sysinstall. Specifically, the file
   src/release/Makefile, and dist.c, dist.h, menus.c, install.c, and
   Makefile will need to be updated under src/usr.sbin/sysinstall.
   Optionally, you may choose to update sysinstall.8.

   If an alternate version of XFree86 is to be provided, then
   sysinstall(8) must be updated to reflect the new location and
   installation instructions. The relevant code is contained in
   src/usr.sbin/sysinstall. Specifically, the files dist.c, menus.c,
   and config.c will need to be updated.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

    3.4.2 Disc 2

   The second disc is also largely created by make release. This disc
   contains a "live filesystem" that can be used from sysinstall(8)
   to troubleshoot a FreeBSD installation. This disc should be
   bootable and should also contain a compressed copy of the CVS
   repository in the CVSROOT directory and commercial software demos
   in the commerce directory.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

    3.4.3 Discs 3 and 4

   The remaining two discs contain additional software packages for
   FreeBSD. The packages should be clustered so that a package and
   all of its dependencies are included on the same disc. More
   information about the creation of these discs is provided in the
   The Release Engineering of Third Party Packages article.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

    3.4.4 Multi-volume support

   Sysinstall supports multiple volume package installations. This
   requires that each disc have an INDEX file containing all of the
   packages on all volumes of a set, along with an extra field that
   indicates which volume that particular package is on. Each volume
   in the set must also have the CD_VOLUME variable set in the
   cdrom.inf file so that sysinstall can tell which volume is which.
   When a user attempts to install a package that is not on the
   current disc, sysinstall will prompt the user to insert the
   appropriate one.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

4 Distribution

  4.1 FTP Sites

   When the release has been thoroughly tested and packaged for
   distribution, the master FTP site must be updated. The official
   FreeBSD public FTP sites are all mirrors of a master server that
   is open only to other FTP sites. This site is known as ftp-master.
   When the release is ready, the following files must be modified on
   ftp-master:

   /pub/FreeBSD/releases/arch/X.Y-RELEASE/

           The installable FTP directory as output from make release.

   /pub/FreeBSD/ports/arch/packages-X.Y-release/

           The complete package build for this release.

   /pub/FreeBSD/releases/arch/X.Y-RELEASE/tools

           A symlink to ../../../tools.

   /pub/FreeBSD/releases/arch/X.Y-RELEASE/packages

           A symlink to ../../../ports/arch/packages-X.Y-release.

   /pub/FreeBSD/releases/arch/ISO-IMAGES/X.Y/X.Y-RELEASE-arch-*.iso

           The ISO images. The "*" is disc1, disc2, etc. Only if
           there is a disc1 and there is an alternative first
           installation CD (for example a stripped-down install with
           no windowing system) there may be a mini as well.

   For more information about the distribution mirror architecture of
   the FreeBSD FTP sites, please see the Mirroring FreeBSD article.

   It may take many hours to two days after updating ftp-master
   before a majority of the Tier-1 FTP sites have the new software
   depending on whether or not a package set got loaded at the same
   time. It is imperative that the release engineers coordinate with
   the FreeBSD mirror site administrators before announcing the
   general availability of new software on the FTP sites. Ideally the
   release package set should be loaded at least four days prior to
   release day. The release bits should be loaded between 24 and 48
   hours before the planned release time with "other" file
   permissions turned off. This will allow the mirror sites to
   download it but the general public will not be able to download it
   from the mirror sites. Mail should be sent to FreeBSD mirror site
   administrators at the time the release bits get posted saying the
   release has been staged and giving the time that the mirror sites
   should begin allowing access. Be sure to include a time zone with
   the time, for example make it relative to GMT.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  4.2 CD-ROM Replication

   Coming soon: Tips for sending FreeBSD ISOs to a replicator and
   quality assurance measures to be taken.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

5 Extensibility

   Although FreeBSD forms a complete operating system, there is
   nothing that forces you to use the system exactly as we have
   packaged it up for distribution. We have tried to design the
   system to be as extensible as possible so that it can serve as a
   platform that other commercial products can be built on top of.
   The only "rule" we have about this is that if you are going to
   distribute FreeBSD with non-trivial changes, we encourage you to
   document your enhancements! The FreeBSD community can only help
   support users of the software we provide. We certainly encourage
   innovation in the form of advanced installation and administration
   tools, for example, but we cannot be expected to answer questions
   about it.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  5.1 Creating Customized Boot floppies

   Many sites have complex requirements that may require additional
   kernel modules or userland tools be added to the installation
   floppies. The "quick and dirty" way to accomplish this would be to
   modify the staging directory of an existing make release build
   hierarchy:

     * Apply patches or add additional files inside the chroot
       release build directory.

     * rm ${CHROOTDIR}/usr/obj/usr/src/release/release.[59]

     * rebuild sysinstall(8), the kernel, or whatever parts of the
       system your change affected.

     * chroot ${CHROOTDIR} ./mk floppies

   New release floppies will be located in
   ${CHROOTDIR}/R/stage/floppies.

   Alternatively, the boot.flp make target can be called, or the
   filesystem creating script, src/release/scripts/doFS.sh, may be
   invoked directly.

   Local patches may also be supplied to the release build by
   defining the LOCAL_PATCH variable in make release.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

  5.2 Scripting sysinstall

   The FreeBSD system installation and configuration tool,
   sysinstall(8), can be scripted to provide automated installs for
   large sites. This functionality can be used in conjunction with
   Intel(R) PXE[12] to bootstrap systems from the network, or via
   custom boot floppies with a sysinstall script. An example
   sysinstall script is available in the CVS tree as
   src/usr.sbin/sysinstall/install.cfg.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

6 Lessons Learned from FreeBSD 4.4

   The release engineering process for 4.4 formally began on August
   1st, 2001. After that date all commits to the RELENG_4 branch of
   FreeBSD had to be explicitly approved by the Release Engineering
   Team <re@FreeBSD.org>. The first release candidate for the x86
   architecture was released on August 16, followed by 4 more release
   candidates leading up to the final release on September 18th. The
   security officer was very involved in the last week of the process
   as several security issues were found in the earlier release
   candidates. A total of over 500 emails were sent to the Release
   Engineering Team <re@FreeBSD.org> in little over a month.

   Our user community has made it very clear that the security and
   stability of a FreeBSD release should not be sacrificed for any
   self-imposed deadlines or target release dates. The FreeBSD
   Project has grown tremendously over its lifetime and the need for
   standardized release engineering procedures has never been more
   apparent. This will become even more important as FreeBSD is
   ported to new platforms.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

7 Future Directions

   It is imperative for our release engineering activities to scale
   with our growing userbase. Along these lines we are working very
   hard to document the procedures involved in producing FreeBSD
   releases.

     * Parallelism - Certain portions of the release build are
       actually "embarrassingly parallel". Most of the tasks are very
       I/O intensive, so having multiple high-speed disk drives is
       actually more important than using multiple processors in
       speeding up the make release process. If multiple disks are
       used for different hierarchies in the chroot(2) environment,
       then the CVS checkout of the ports and doc trees can be
       happening simultaneously as the make world on another disk.
       Using a RAID solution (hardware or software) can significantly
       decrease the overall build time.

     * Cross-building releases - Building IA-64 or Alpha release on
       x86 hardware? make TARGET=ia64 release.

     * Regression Testing - We need better automated correctness
       testing for FreeBSD.

     * Installation Tools - Our installation program has long since
       outlived its intended life span. Several projects are under
       development to provide a more advanced installation mechanism.
       The libh project was one such project that aimed to provide an
       intelligent new package framework and GUI installation
       program.

     --------------------------------------------------------------

8 Acknowledgements

   I would like to thank Jordan Hubbard for giving me the opportunity
   to take on some of the release engineering responsibilities for
   FreeBSD 4.4 and also for all of his work throughout the years
   making FreeBSD what it is today. Of course the release would not
   have been possible without all of the release-related work done by
   Satoshi Asami <asami@FreeBSD.org>, Steve Price
   <steve@FreeBSD.org>, Bruce A. Mah <bmah@FreeBSD.org>, Nik Clayton
   <nik@FreeBSD.org>, David O'Brien <obrien@FreeBSD.org>, Kris
   Kennaway <kris@FreeBSD.org>, John Baldwin <jhb@FreeBSD.org> and
   the rest of the FreeBSD development community. I would also like
   to thank Rodney Grimes <rgrimes@FreeBSD.org>, Poul-Henning Kamp
   <phk@FreeBSD.org>, and others who worked on the release
   engineering tools in the very early days of FreeBSD. This article
   was influenced by release engineering documents from the CSRG[13],
   the NetBSD Project[10], and John Baldwin's proposed release
   engineering process notes[11].

     --------------------------------------------------------------

9 References

   [1] CVS - Concurrent Versions System http://www.cvshome.org

   [2] CVSup - The CVS-Optimized General Purpose Network File
   Distribution System http://www.polstra.com/projects/freeware/CVSup

   [3] http://pointyhat.FreeBSD.org

   [4] FreeBSD Ports Collection http://www.FreeBSD.org/ports

   [5] FreeBSD Committers
   http://www.FreeBSD.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/articles/contributors/staff-committers.html

   [6] FreeBSD Core Team
   http://www.FreeBSD.org/administration.html#t-core

   [7] FreeBSD Handbook
   http://www.FreeBSD.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/books/handbook

   [8] GNATS: The GNU Bug Tracking System
   http://www.gnu.org/software/gnats

   [9] FreeBSD PR Statistics
   http://www.FreeBSD.org/prstats/index.html

   [10] NetBSD Developer Documentation: Release Engineering
   http://www.NetBSD.org/developers/releng/index.html

   [11] John Baldwin's FreeBSD Release Engineering Proposal
   http://people.FreeBSD.org/~jhb/docs/releng.txt

   [12] PXE Jumpstart Guide
   http://www.FreeBSD.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/articles/pxe/index.html

   [13] Marshall Kirk McKusick, Michael J. Karels, and Keith Bostic:
   The Release Engineering of 4.3BSD

     --------------------------------------------------------------
